Thurby Scratch Updates – 5/2/2024

BACK TO THURBY PICKS

Updated Race Picks Summary Table

Race NumberWin PickConfidencePlace PickConfidenceShow PickConfidence
1Chiquita ReinaHighIuka MissMediumGather The FactsMedium
2Noble BernadetteHighK’antheiaMediumMor Happy HoursMedium
3Pounds in TownHighCalcetinesHighMiss ElleMedium
4Closethegame SugarHighAchieveMediumMajor BlueMedium
5Modern Day WarriorHighRocky JoyMediumBrillian BertiMedium
6Classic LegacyHighShopper’s RevengeMediumEarl of DasselLow
7Generous LoverHighIn ColorHighSassy WalkerMedium
8Dripping GoldHighRisk ManagerHighReady to PurrformMedium
9Jet Sweep JoeMediumMensaMediumStrumminLow
10BangoHighO BesosHighSurveillanceMedium
11Carl SpacklerHighIce ChocolatHighHarlan EstateMedium
12Mucho MojoHighAmerican HeroMediumSant’ AntimoMedium
High Confidence: Strong likelihood based on consistent results and solid alignment with race conditions.
Medium Confidence: Good potential but acknowledges the possibility of competitive dynamics or variability.
Low Confidence: Indicates speculative choices with potential but acknowledged risks due to variability in past performance.

Updated Best Bets of the Day Table

Bet TypeSelectionsReasoning
Win of the DayRace 12: Mucho MojoUnmatched speed and class in today’s races.
Place of the DayRace 7: In ColorConsistent track performance and high adaptability.
Show of the DayRace 4: Major BlueSolid form and potential despite competitive field.
W/P/S of the DayRace 11: Carl SpacklerDominant across metrics and expected conditions.
Exacta of the DayRace 8: Dripping Gold, Risk ManagerStrongest contenders with top Prime Power.
Trifecta of the DayRace 5: Modern Day Warrior, Rocky Joy, Brilliant BertiAdjusted for scratches, still a strong lineup for varied race conditions.
Superfecta of the DayRace 9: Jet Sweep Joe, Mensa, Strummin, Tuxedo ParkVaried strengths covering potential race outcomes.
Double of the DayRaces 11 & 12: Carl Spackler, Mucho MojoPairing of the strongest contenders in sequential races.
Pick 4 of the DayRaces 9 to 12: Jet Sweep Joe, Mensa; Bango, O Besos; Carl Spackler, Ice Chocolat, Harlan Estate; Mucho Mojo, American Hero, Sant’ AntimoStrong chance of success across these races, adapting to the dynamics and runner changes.

Race 1:

Revised Analysis for Race 1:

  • Win: With Morning Miracle out, Chiquita Reina moves up as the new favorite for the win. Given her strong performance metrics that were only slightly behind Morning Miracle, she now stands as the top contender. Her ability to handle this distance and her proven form make her well-suited to take the lead.
  • Place: Iuka Miss now steps up into the Place prediction. Previously listed for Show, her consistent finishes and compatibility with the race conditions, such as the track surface and distance, make her a stronger candidate now in the absence of Morning Miracle.
  • Show: Gather The Facts moves into the Show position. This horse has shown potential with decent past performances and may benefit from a slightly less competitive field with the removal of one of the top contenders. Her ability to perform under these race conditions and her mid-tier Prime Power rating position her as a possible top-three finisher.

Impact on Betting Strategy:

  • The scratch of a favored horse often leads to changes in betting odds and strategies. Bettors may see improved odds on other horses like Chiquita Reina and Iuka Miss, who now have increased chances of winning or placing higher.
  • It’s important to reconsider trifecta and superfecta bets, as the dynamics have shifted. Adjustments in bets that involved Morning Miracle are necessary to accommodate her absence.
  • The overall pace and strategy of the race might change with Morning Miracle’s scratch, as she may have been a pace setter or a strong early contender.

Updated Confidence Ratings:

  • Chiquita Reina: Confidence moves to High, given her new status as the top contender with fewer challenges.
  • Iuka Miss: Confidence remains at Medium. While her chances have improved, the shift in race dynamics might still present new challenges.
  • Gather The Facts: Confidence is Low to Medium, reflecting her entry into top-three considerations but recognizing that she has less proven performance at this level compared to the others.

Conclusion:

The absence of Morning Miracle definitely shakes up the predictions for Race 1, shifting the focus to Chiquita Reina and Iuka Miss as the new leaders of the pack. Adjusting your betting strategy to account for these changes will be crucial for capitalizing on the new race setup. Keep an eye on the updated odds and any further developments that might impact race conditions or other entries.

Race 3:

Revised Analysis for Race 3:

  • Win: Pounds in Town remains the top pick for the win. Her high Prime Power rating and excellent recent form suggest she’s still well-positioned to dominate this race, even with the changes in the lineup.
  • Place: Calcetines, previously picked as a strong contender for Place, remains in this position. With two competitors out, his chances improve given his consistent performance and suitability to the distance and track conditions.
  • Show: Miss Elle now steps up into the Show position. She was previously considered on the edge due to her running style and recent performances which align well with the conditions of this race. Her potential is more pronounced with fewer competitors.

Impact on Betting Strategy:

  • The scratches may alter the betting odds, potentially providing better returns on horses like Miss Elle, who now has a clearer path to placing in the top three.
  • Bettors should reconsider multi-horse bets such as trifectas and superfectas, as the field has thinned, changing the dynamics of the race.
  • Pacing and tactical approaches by the jockeys could shift, as Melittlefrostgirl and Run Camila Run might have influenced the early race pace.

Updated Confidence Ratings:

  • Pounds in Town: Confidence remains High. Her superiority in terms of form and ratings is even more evident with fewer contenders.
  • Calcetines: Confidence is boosted to High, considering his enhanced likelihood of placing with the reduced competition.
  • Miss Elle: Confidence shifts to Medium. While she moves up in prediction, her performance needs to match this newfound opportunity.

Conclusion:

The scratches of Melittlefrostgirl, Run Camila Run, and Achieve notably thin the competition for Race 3, consolidating the focus on Pounds in Town and improving the odds for Calcetines and Miss Elle to perform well. This streamlined field should prompt bettors to update their strategies, focusing on the now more likely outcomes based on the remaining contenders’ strengths and track conditions. Always reassess the race dynamics and potential impact of scratches right up to post time to maximize betting success.

Race #5

Revised Analysis for Race 5:

Given the scratch of Juan Valdez, who was a top contender:

  • Win: Modern Day Warrior now moves up to the Win position. Originally picked for Place, his strong performance metrics and suitability for the distance and surface make him the new favorite.
  • Place: Rocky Joy also moves up from Show to Place. His consistency and adaptability to the track conditions, along with his good pace, make him well-suited to take a higher position.
  • Show: Brilliant Berti is now elevated to the Show position. He has shown potential with competitive past performances and should now be considered a stronger candidate for finishing in the top three.

Race #8

The scratches of The Prince’s Spur, Fair Dinkum, Wind Twist, and Hidden Stash have no impact on picks.

Race #9

The scratch of The Queens M G has no impact on picks.

Race #10

The scratch of Richesonaroll has no impact on picks

Revised Analysis for Race 10:

  • Win: Bango remains the top pick for Win. His superior class and speed stats suggest he’s well-suited to lead the field.
  • Place: O Besos also remains in Place, continuing to show strong potential with consistent performances and good adaptability to race conditions.
  • Show: With Manny Wah out, Surveillance is elevated to the Show position. Surveillance has demonstrated solid form in recent races and has the potential to step up in a less competitive field.

Race #11

Revised Picks for Race 11:

  • Win: Carl Spackler
  • Place: Ice Chocolat
  • Show: Harlan Estate (revised pick) — Elevated to Show due to his decent performances and suitability to the race conditions, making him the next best candidate based on available data.

Impact on Picks of the Day:

  • Double of the Day (Races 11 & 12): The Double of the Day was initially Carl Spackler and Mucho Mojo. Quality G was also highlighted as a part of another Daily Double suggestion. Given Quality G’s scratch, bettors should now solely focus on Carl Spackler for Race 11 in these combinations, maintaining confidence in the bet, albeit with adjusted expectations.
  • Updated Pick 4 of the Day
    • Race 9: Jet Sweep Joe, Mensa
    • Race 10: Bango, O Besos
    • Race 11: Carl Spackler, Ice Chocolat, Harlan Estate
    • Race 12: Mucho Mojo, American Hero
    • Rationale for the Revised Pick 4:
    • Consistency and Potential: The revised selections ensure consistency and adaptability in the changing dynamics of Race 11 while maintaining strong contenders across all four races.
    • Balanced Approach: Including Harlan Estate as a replacement maintains a balanced approach to potential outcomes, ensuring that the picks remain competitive and reflective of the race conditions and entrants’ capabilities.

Conclusion:

The scratches of Ah Jeez and especially Quality G in Race 11 necessitate a modification to the Show prediction, with Harlan Estate now recommended to fill this spot. The rest of the “picks of the day” involving Race 11 remain robust but should be reviewed for potential impact, particularly in multi-race wagers like the Double where Quality G was previously considered a strong contender. Bettors should adjust their strategies accordingly, considering these new dynamics for a successful day at the races.

Race #12

Revised Picks for Race 12:

  • Win: Mucho Mojo
  • Place: American Hero
  • Show: Sant’ Antimo (new pick) — Selected based on his promising performances and potential in similar race conditions, making him a strong candidate to round out the top three.

Impact on Picks of the Day:

  • Pick 4 of the Day (Races 9 to 12): The original selection included Mucho Mojo and American Hero for Race 12. The scratch of Power Alley requires us to replace him in this multi-race wager. Sant’ Antimo is now included as a replacement to maintain a robust strategy across the four races.

Updated Pick 4 of the Day

  • Race 9: Jet Sweep Joe, Mensa
  • Race 10: Bango, O Besos
  • Race 11: Carl Spackler, Ice Chocolat, Harlan Estate
  • Race 12: Mucho Mojo, American Hero, Sant’ Antimo

Conclusion:

The scratches of Seven Flat and Power Alley in Race 12 lead us to adjust our Show pick to Sant’ Antimo, ensuring the strength and continuity of our selections for individual and multi-race bets. The revision in the Pick 4 of the Day reflects this change, adapting our strategy to the updated race conditions and participants. Bettors should review these changes to align their betting strategies accordingly, ensuring they remain well-positioned to capitalize on the day’s races at Churchill Downs.